What's Better for Garden - Compost or Manure

compost and manure


Welcome, gardening enthusiasts and beginners alike! If you've ever wondered whether compost or manure is better for your garden, you're not alone. This age-old debate has passionate advocates on both sides, each praising the virtues of these natural fertilizers. In this guide, we'll dive deep into understanding the basics of compost and manure, comparing their nutritional benefits, and exploring the best application techniques to transform your garden into a lush paradise.

You'll discover the cost-effectiveness of each option, and understand their environmental benefits for sustainable gardening. We'll also highlight common pitfalls to avoid. By the end of this post, you'll have all the knowledge you need to make an informed choice for your garden's health and productivity. So, let's dig in and uncover the secrets of compost and manure:

Compost vs. Manure

Nutritional Benefits: Comparing Compost and Manure

Is Compost or Manure More Budget-Friendly?

Mistakes to Avoid with Compost and Manure


Compost vs. Manure

Both compost and manure are valuable additions to your garden, but they serve different roles.

Compost is great for improving soil texture and adding a wide range of nutrients and beneficial microbes. It’s also an excellent way to recycle organic waste.

Manure, with its high nitrogen content, is particularly effective for boosting plant growth, especially for leafy vegetables. However, it must be handled carefully to avoid potential issues with pathogens and plant damage.



Nutritional Benefits: Comparing Compost and Manure

When it comes to enriching your garden soil, understanding the nutritional benefits of compost and manure is essential. Both provide vital nutrients but in different ways, affecting how you should use them in your garden.


Compost is often lauded for its ability to improve soil health. It is rich in organic matter, which enhances soil structure and water retention. Compost provides a variety of essential nutrients, such as nitrogen, phosphorus, and potassium, which are gradually released to plants. These nutrients are crucial for plant growth and development.

Moreover, compost fosters a healthy soil ecosystem. It encourages the growth of beneficial microorganisms that help decompose organic matter, further enriching the soil. This biological activity helps suppress plant diseases and pests, creating a more resilient garden environment. The slow release of nutrients from compost ensures that plants have a steady supply over time, reducing the risk of nutrient leaching and groundwater contamination.


Manure, particularly aged or composted manure, is another powerful soil amendment. It is notably high in nitrogen, which is essential for leafy plant growth. Manure offers essential nutrients, but it must be composted or aged before being safely used in gardens. Fresh manure can be too potent and may burn plants or introduce pathogens.

Aged manure provides a rich source of nitrogen, phosphorus, and potassium. These nutrients are readily available to plants, making manure an excellent option for boosting soil fertility quickly. However, because manure is high in nitrogen, it is particularly beneficial for crops that require significant amounts of this nutrient, such as corn, lettuce, and other leafy greens.

In addition to its nutrient content, manure also improves soil structure and increases water-holding capacity. This can be particularly beneficial in sandy soils that struggle to retain moisture. By incorporating manure into your garden, you not only supply essential nutrients but also enhance the overall health and productivity of your soil.

Compost vs. Manure: Which is Better?

Both compost and manure have their unique advantages. Compost is ideal for general soil improvement and long-term nutrient release. It’s perfect for enriching garden beds, improving soil texture, and promoting a healthy soil ecosystem. Manure, with its high nitrogen content, is excellent for giving a quick nutrient boost to heavy feeders and improving soil fertility rapidly.



Is Compost or Manure More Budget-Friendly?

When deciding between compost and manure for your garden, cost is an important factor. Both options offer different financial implications depending on how you source and use them.


Creating your own compost at home is often the most budget-friendly option. Home composting can be cost-free if you utilize kitchen scraps, yard waste, and other organic materials you already have. This DIY approach not only saves money but also reduces waste, making it an environmentally friendly choice.

However, if you prefer to buy compost, prices can vary. Bagged compost from garden centers can be convenient but may add up in cost, especially for larger gardens. Bulk compost, available from local suppliers, can be more economical for significant amounts. Investing in a quality compost bin or composter, like the Neakasa Kitchen Compost Bin (click to appy $30 promo code) can streamline the process and offer long-term savings.


Manure is often low-cost, especially when sourced directly from local farms. Many farmers farmers are often eager to sell or even provide manure for free, particularly if you can transport it yourself. This makes manure a cost-effective option for many gardeners. However, be aware that transporting large quantities can involve additional costs and labor.

Bagged manure from garden centers is typically more expensive than sourcing it directly but offers convenience and consistency. The cost can be justified if you need smaller amounts or if you lack access to local farms. Manure also requires aging or composting, which could involve additional time and resources.


Mistakes to Avoid with Compost and Manure

Using compost and manure in your garden can significantly improve soil health and plant growth, but it's essential to avoid common mistakes to reap the full benefits. Here are some key pitfalls to watch out for when using these organic fertilizers.

Compost Mistakes

1. Improper Balance of Green and Brown Materials:

Successful composting requires a proper balance of green (nitrogen-rich) and brown (carbon-rich) materials. A common mistake is not maintaining the correct balance of green and brown materials, resulting in a compost pile that becomes either too wet or too dry. Too much green material can make the pile slimy and smelly, while too much brown material can slow down decomposition .

2. Adding Meat or Dairy Products:

Meat and dairy products should be avoided in compost piles. They can attract pests and create unpleasant odors. Including meat, bones, and dairy products in your compost can attract pests and create unpleasant odors.

3. Not Turning the Pile Regularly:

Turning the compost pile is essential to aerate it and speed up decomposition. "Failing to turn the compost pile regularly can result in uneven decomposition and a slower process". Regular turning ensures that oxygen reaches all parts of the pile, promoting the activity of aerobic microorganisms that break down organic matter.

4. Using Diseased Plants:

Avoid adding diseased plants to your compost. Composting diseased plants can introduce pathogens and create issues in your garden. Ensure that the compost pile reaches a high enough temperature to kill any potential pathogens.

To avoid these common composting mistakes and streamline your composting process, consider using the Neakasa Electric Composter. This innovative composter helps maintain the right balance of materials, controls odors, and simplifies the composting process, making it easier to produce high-quality compost.

neakasa compost bin


Manure Mistakes

1. Using Fresh Manure:

   Fresh manure, with its high nitrogen content, can be too potent and may burn plants. It also harbors pathogens harmful to both humans and plants, so it must be composted or aged before use to prevent damage.

2. Over-Application:

   Applying too much manure can lead to nutrient imbalances and environmental issues. Applying excessive amounts can result in nutrient runoff that contaminates water sources. Therefore, it's essential to use manure in moderation and adhere to recommended application rates.

3. Applying Manure Too Close to Harvest Time:

   To avoid introducing harmful pathogens to fruits and vegetables, manure should be applied long before planting, especially for edible crops, rather than close to harvest time. Follow the guideline of applying manure at least 90 days before harvesting crops that grow above ground and 120 days before harvesting root crops.

4. Using Manure from Unknown Sources:

   Ensure the manure you use is from a reliable source. Manure from unknown sources can contain unwanted contaminants, such as antibiotics, hormones, or pesticides. Introducing manure from unverified sources can lead to contamination in your garden.



In conclusion, both compost and manure offer unique and powerful benefits for enhancing garden soil and promoting healthy plant growth. 

Compost excels at improving soil structure, enriching it with a diverse range of nutrients, and supporting a healthy soil ecosystem. Manure, particularly when aged or composted, provides a quick and potent boost of nitrogen, ideal for heavy-feeding plants. 

The choice between compost and manure ultimately depends on your specific gardening needs, resources, and environmental goals. By understanding the distinct advantages of each, you can make an informed decision that best supports your garden’s vitality. 

Ready to take your gardening to the next level? Explore the Neakasa Kitchen Composter to effortlessly create high-quality compost and start transforming your garden today.

Reading next

neakasa kitchen composter
makoa standing on Neakasa Cat Litter Box

Leave a comment

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.